Betrayal Trauma Recovery
Podcast Episode:

His Blame Shifting Wrecks Your Confidence? Hold onto THIS

Here are some issues you may not have thought of. Find out what you need to know. 

Listen

Listen on any platform

Read

One of the most harmful tactics emotionally abusive husbands use to control their wives is blame shifting.

Many women who come to BTR for help describe how they’ve been blamed for their husband’s choices over and over by him and therapists or clergy. They’ve been told that the way they think, feel, act, speak, and look has somehow made their husband treat her with contempt.

To know if you’re experiencing any one of the 19 types of abuse, take our free abuse quiz.

Featurism Ways It Impacts Women in Marriage

Below are six ways an emotionally abusive husband uses blame shifting to undermine his wife’s confidence.

1. HOW HIS BLAME SHIFTING BECOMES THE VOICE IN HER HEAD

Emotionally abusive men often use manufactured explanations and outside reinforcement to exploit their wives intelligence, kindness, and willingness to self-reflect in order to work through problems together.

He might say she’s “suspicious” or “jealous” if she mentions something about his texting a female co-worker at all hours of the night. Or he might compare her to other women who look so “put together.” Leading her to believe that somehow her character, appearance, or functionality is the root issue behind the issues in their relationship.

After hearing that message repeatedly, she may find herself thinking, “Maybe I am just being suspicious or jealous.” Or “maybe if I lost some weight and became more organized he’d be less frustrated with me and wouldn’t seek attention from other women.”

His criticism and accusations can start to sound reasonable and changing herself becomes the solution.

That’s how his blame shifting becomes the voice in her head.

Featurism Impacts Married Women

2. BLAME SHIFTING CONDITIONS HER TO STOP ASKING QUESTIONS

When an emotionally abusive man meets his wife’s concerns with anger, yelling, or leaving for hours with no contact or confirmation of his whereabouts, it can condition her to just stop asking. Even when she’s carefully rehearsed her questions and found considerate, less disruptive ways to have difficult conversations, he’ll likely have the same response.

This blame-shifting pattern moves attention away from what he did and onto her timing, tone, and wording. It becomes clear that there is no good way to ask a question or resolve issues and that her silence is the only solution.

If you’re caught in this confusing loop and need support to keep you grounded Check out our daily online Group Session schedule.

3. HE USES THERAPY TO REINFORCE HIS PERSPECTIVE

When the confusion in a marriage with an emotionally abusive husband reaches the point that his wife can’t take it anymore, a common next step is couple therapy, but that’s often exactly what he’s counting on.

Most couple therapy models treat problems in marriage as 50/50 and therapists are often not equipped to screen for emotional abuse. He looks like a willing partner when he shows up for sessions. And it sounds reasonable for him to point to her anger, un-willingness to let things go, shaming him, or even triggering his childhood trauma as explanations for his behavior.

To learn how to deal with this type of abuse in a strategic way, enroll in The Betrayal Trauma Recovery Workshop.

4. HE MAKES HER REACTIONS EQUAL TO HIS BETRAYAL

Emotionally abusive men typically wanted the scales to be balanced. Like, they’ll make the fact that their wives don’t greet them enthusiastically at the door with a smile as the same type of offense as his choosing to go to the bar for hours when he knew she needed help with a sick child at home.

Or he might be offended if she rolls her eyes when he accuses her of being disrespectful for asking him to not to put his wet towels on the bed. Now, Her facial expression is put on the scale alongside his contempt, creating an argument that she has something of equal weight to answer for.

A woman can become so accustomed to defending herself that she stops asking whether the accusation makes sense.

5. HE MAKES HER APPEARANCE A CONDITION FOR HIS LOVE

He may treat his wife poorly and tell her it’s because he’s not attracted to her anymore, after she’s spent years supporting him and caring for him, their home, and family without conditions. Making conditions of love, care, or consideration based on her features reduces his wife to an object, not a person.

She may start believing that changing her appearance will secure his love again or at least better treatment.

Your body and features are in now way responsible for his mistreatment of you.

6. HE MOVES THE GOALPOSTS

An emotionally abusive husband who is constantly projecting the blame onto his wife by telling her that she needs to do X, Y, and Z in order to be good enough or to be worthy enough…” will inevitably need to move the goalposts when he needs to keep his deception covered.

The requirements for his wife’s appearance, household work, emotional and sexual availability, and or her lack of improvement are interpreted as evidence the issue.

You don’t have to be or look perfect to deserve love, respect, honesty, and emotional safety.

What is Featurism Ways It Impacts Women in Marriage

TRANSCRIPT: HOW HE USES BLAME SHIFTING TO UNDERMINE YOU

Anne: I have a member of our community on today’s episode. We’re gonna call her Audrey. Welcome, 📍 📍 Audrey.

Thank you so much Audrey for coming on today to share your story. Why don’t we just start right into it. Can you talk about how you felt about him in the beginning?

Audrey: He was like a knight in shining armor. We had met earlier on in our young adulthood, and then we met later on and it was like the meant to be moment. Things went really fast. I took that as this wonderful sign that we were supposed to be together.

He definitely drew me in very quickly. He was this amazing man that I thought I was not good enough to actually be with honestly. It was surreal.

Anne: When you say that you didn’t feel good enough he was giving you the feeling that you weren’t good enough?

Audrey: Oh, absolutely. I relive that so many times in my mind and I’m now able to see and extract those exact interactions. Whether it was always comparing me to his exes, but yet at the same time acting like I’m so much better than them. But me always feeling like I wasn’t. So it was this backhanded compliment, but at the same time a put down.

I remember always feeling a level of confusion in our relationship from the very beginning. I would dismiss it ’cause he would always have a great explanation and he was love bombing. It was definitely something that I felt I wasn’t good enough and yet I was hearing that message from him.

WHEN HIS BLAME SHIFTING SOUNDS LIKE YOUR OWN THOUGHTS

Anne: This is one thing that’s so hard for us to understand, that their manipulation and blame shifting is so good that we think it’s our own thoughts. We think we came up with it. We think, “Oh, he is so amazing. And we’re so lucky. Why did he pick me when I’ve got all these problems?”

Not realizing that wait, I am amazing. And of course he was gonna pick me. The feeling of not being good enough is coming from him, even though he’s not overtly saying that. He’s not overtly putting you down. ‘Cause you would definitely notice. When women talk to me and they say things like, “I’m not good enough.”

I think, is that really your thoughts or is that the thing that he’s implanted into you?

Audrey: Oh, absolutely. It just reminded me throughout our entire relationship and even now in this process, I was constantly being told by everybody outside of our circle or even in our circle: what a great guy he was. “Oh my gosh, how did you get so lucky with this guy?”

And his family members would even tell me like if I ever broke his heart, I’d have to answer to them, there’s be prices to pay for me. I was like, “Who have I met?” He’s this great person.

He was in the medical field and early on he did some miraculous work with a family member of mine. Everybody from that point out was like, “He’s amazing. He saved our family member, what would we do without him?”

So absolutely He was always way on a pedestal above me.

REALIZING SOMETHING ELSE IS GOING ON

Anne: When did you start to notice that maybe he wasn’t as amazing as everybody thought? Or maybe he’s still incredible, but he’s got a problem with something. He’s struggling with something.

When did that sort of come into the story?

Audrey: it’s crazy because I can remember even back when we were dating, before I got pregnant with our first child, there would be little signs. I would pick up on his behaviors or his anger. His interaction with other women was completely alarming to me. Things that I look back now and I tell myself, “Why did you tolerate that? Why did you allow that?” It was hearing the conflicting messages. My heart’s telling me one thing. People outside are telling me another thing.

He’s telling me something else. It must be me. I must not be understanding him correctly. It was always so confusing. Now that I look back and I can see things more clearly, I’m able to understand how it was made to be confusing.

He purposely did that. He would push me out, pull me in, push me out, pull me in constantly. All I longed for was to be pulled back in.

Anne: Mm-hmm.

Audrey: Over and over again.

HOW HE USES BLAME SHIFTING TO GET WHAT HE WANTS

Anne: Those pushed out times are interesting. I wrote about this in my book.

I don’t know if they necessarily do it to keep us confused. Though that is the effect, definitely what occurs. I think in those moments, they have something that they want. They have a goal and we don’t know what that goal is, and it might be to be alone so that they can text an affair partner. It might be so they can leave the house and do something.

It might be so they can watch football and not have to do the dishes. I don’t know what the thing is. We don’t know either. When they push us away and they’re not telling us the truth. They could in a kind way say, I don’t wanna talk to you right now. I would really rather leave the house and go to a bar with my friends.

Audrey: Yeah.

Anne: But instead we get pushed away and they are like, “You are so much, I have to leave, or I to go into my room, or I have to do something. “

Audrey: Oh, absolutely.

Anne: So it really comes down to lying because they’re not being completely honest about saying, “I’m never gonna do the dishes, and so instead I am gonna act like I’m so offended that you asked me about my day while you happen to be handing me a dish.” It creates a lot of confusion.

Audrey: Early on in our relationship, I wasn’t able to recognize it as something so intentional. He’d purposely start arguments over anything and then blow up and leave. Sometimes it would be for an hour, sometimes it would be for hours, sometimes it would be for days.

And this was a pattern that went on through our entire marriage. I just saw as he just had enough, he just had to have space.

But now I see the manipulation in it. I see the control in it, and the intention that he literally would do that to get out of whatever it was. I don’t even know what he was doing at those times, but it’s very confusing.

Anne: If you go to couple therapy or if you talk to clergy… whoever a couple goes to to get help in these instances, they’re going to take his reasons seriously. Instead of realizing they were just lies and blame shifting. Can you talk about how that played out?

HOW COUPLE THERAPY MISSES THE REAL PROBLEM

Audrey: So early on when I started feeling so confused and I was trying to reach out to family members or friends and be like, “Hey, do you experience this in your marriage? Does your husband get this angry and just leave the house and turn off his location or not tell you where he is going? Is this normal? ’cause I’ve never been married.”

And a lot of my friends would be like. “No, but he’s probably just stressed. He’s probably just whatever.” And at the same time I’m thinking, Okay, maybe that’s just how he expresses himself. So anyway, as this progressed, I finally was like, we need professional help.

Anne: Um hmm

Audrey: We started looking into options for marriage counseling. For me it was really important to have somebody to help us align our marriage with our faith.

We found some priests. We started down that avenue. I can’t even tell you how many times it was shifted back to me. If I would just… He’s working, he’s experiencing a lot of changes in his life being newly married and then it started coming into his childhood trauma.

And this is all his childhood trauma and I am somehow always increasing his shame or I somehow just need to be nicer or more understanding. It added to the mental confusion for myself to think, again, it’s me. He’s telling it’s me. The counselors are telling me it’s me.

And so if I could just fix me, our marriage would be better. That’s a really hard place to be because when every counselor’s telling you this, every therapist is telling us this. You keep bending and turning and contorting and nothing changes. Through his personal therapy with his childhood trauma, he came to the discovery of sex addiction.

HOW HE TRAINS YOU TO IGNORE YOUR GUT

Anne: Did you find anything before this? Did you discover that he was using pornography or having an affair or anything like that before this claim that he was a sex addict?

Audrey: I always had suspicions that he was talking to other women, coworkers or whatever. He would actually take me and the kids to functions with the other woman, and I wouldn’t even know she was there. Women’s hearts and guts do not lie.

For me, that’s one of the biggest things. He really trained me to ignore my own gut, to ignore my own heart. I would ask him my question of what’s going on. I just feel there’s this disconnect. Again, this is another opportunity for him.

He would get angry, yell, shut it down and leave. So I learned that if I would try to address things that I felt were concerns, that was gonna be the reaction. I learned to just stop asking. Now we have kids and that’s just chaos in the house with the kids watching his reaction.

He would do this at all hours of the night. Even if I tried to have a conversation later when the kids were in bed, it didn’t matter.

If I could just maintain and act like everything was okay, he was a lot more cooperative, reasonable, helpful with the kids, more available to me. But if I spoke my mind, if I tried to bring up a concern, it would get turned off and it’d be anger, rage.

So as long as I just stayed in my lane, didn’t ask questions, the house could be somewhat peaceful. I think that’s a huge part to recognize too.

The sexual addiction came up in his personal therapy with his therapist at that time. Due to his preoccupation with masturbation, extramarital emotional and just apparently kissing affairs, sexual texting, conversations with other women. Due to his inability to stop, because of his childhood trauma, he was a sex addict . That’s how that all came out.

Anne: So he admitted this to the therapist, but not you.

Audrey: No, not by this point.

BLAME SHIFTING HIS BEHAVIOR ONTO AN “ADDICTION”

Anne: Until he said, ” I’ve told the therapist this stuff and the therapist is telling me that I’m a sex addict.”

Audrey: Pretty much, and then we had to have one of those D-Days.

Anne: Yeah. Well, that’s pretty convenient that he tells you the truth about all of this when he has a therapist who is giving him a, I’m gonna say “good reason.”

Audrey: Oh yeah. And he continued to use that reason throughout our marriage, when it was convenient. Other times, and even probably if you asked him today, he’s not a sex addict. He never was a sex addict. He was only being told that by his therapist. And he only agreed to it because somehow I told him he was, or I believed that he was.

It really just depended on, and it still depends on what story he needs and what excuse he needs. He’ll even go back and say, “No, I just kissed her. Or ” wasn’t that big of a deal.” Then, another time he’ll be crying on his knees telling me, “It’s the worst thing.”

It doesn’t make sense. We went through the years and years of counseling and I started doing my own work with sexual addiction codependency. That whole model of me work on myself and he work on himself and then we’ll work this all out together.

That was a huge part of our therapy for many, many, many years.

THE RISK OF SPENDING YEARS IN TREATMENT

Can you talk about when you start realizing, “Wait a minute. Maybe all of this is not going to lead to improvement.” It’s hard because you don’t know, until you’ve tried it.

Let’s say you do sex addiction treatment. When that doesn’t work, well, maybe this therapist isn’t the right therapist. So then you try a different therapist, and then you’re like, “Well, maybe he really needs help with mental illness issues. ” It’s such a risk in time and emotional safety.

The years that it takes to realize if it’s gonna work or not are a risk.

Absolutely, it’s a risk in time. It’s a risk financially. It’s not cheap going to these therapists and extensive amount you have to go. We had young kids. We’re finding, people to watch our kids so he could go once a week. I could go once a week and then we would go together once a week.

That’s a lot of time away from my kids.

It is just a risk all the way around. I look back now and I just think, wow. It was something else. It felt like I almost just lived in a tunnel and there was no end.

But not really seeing any effort from him. And the only time I really could feel like things were okay is if I just chose to literally not ask, don’t think about it, keep working on myself, keep fixing everything in me that was causing his behaviors. Keep the kids under control. And do the best I could. It was just exhausting.

I am guessing none of these therapists brought this to your attention. That his behaviors were abusive.

Absolutely not one.

Wow.

HIS BLAME SHIFTING CONVINCES OTHERS YOU’RE THE PROBLEM

We have quite a number of kids, so I spent all of our marriage, pregnant, raising kids, nursing kids, homeschooling kids for a while.

For a long time there I really just didn’t even wanna live. I just wanted to give up. He ran a wonderful, smear campaign on me with my friends, my own family. I really felt isolated. I lived in survival mode for the longest time, just trying to get through life.

I want to point out that you were going to therapy, so you were trying to get help. They were failing you because they were literally failing to give you the information that you needed to know what was actually happening in your life. You’re surviving this abusive man, but also this abusive system in that you’re not getting the correct information.

If anything, it was reiterating his message to me. the car rides home would be, “See, you need to be more forgiving. See, you shouldn’t be bringing this up all the time. See, how are we ever gonna get anywhere if you can’t let stuff go.”

And I’d be like, ” Okay, it’s always been me, so it just must be me.”

The therapy that we went to just compounded the problem, for all those years, and it didn’t matter who, if it was a guy or a girl, a priest. I was somehow part of the problem. It was exhausting.

WHEN HE SHIFTS BLAME TO THE COUNSELOR

I believe in God’s timing, but there was a long time that through all of this really bad counseling. I was so angry at God for not listening to me or hearing me and feeling so lost and betrayed. Just recently, I now see his hand in everything, and I know that it’s in his timing.

My soon to be ex-husband wanted to try counseling again.

So I said, ” Okay, we can try therapy, but I’m not really wanting to go for marriage therapy. But we need to learn how we’re gonna get along in the house.”

Things were so escalated, so angry in the house. He was yelling and I said, “This is it. You find a therapist. I don’t want it to be Christian or Catholic. It has to be secular.” That was my first thing.

He found somebody and it was this older woman and we started seeing her and she was the first person to actually call it abuse. And I think his reaction was equally astonishing as mine. For his side of things, he was like, ” Huh? Right, okay. And me, I’m like, “Wow, nobody’s ever said that.”

Fast forward a little bit, he decided he was not happy with this counselor obviously, so he wanted to stop.

She encouraged us to still come and then I started seeing her by myself. And then he of course at some point stopped. He said, she was brainwashing me. She was now the problem.

So now her and I we’re the crazy women. Through a little bit of healing with her, I really start to understand what abuse looks like in a different way than just bruises.

FINDING THE RIGHT HELP

There was a situation with our oldest daughter that was life changing for her, with her ex-husband. And when that happened, I knew I need to take a better look at what’s going on in my marriage for my kids.

People were then sharing, your podcast. I think my daughter sent me the first one and I started listening and I couldn’t put ’em down like it was just all day, every day I’d fall asleep in my bed with my earphones In listening, I couldn’t get enough of the information and I just thought, oh my gosh, I was not crazy for all those years. I wasn’t crazy.

It’s interesting ’cause there’s such a relief. Because you’re not crazy and it’s so shocking that no one, in my life, in your life was able to help me see it, even though I was trying so hard to figure it out.

I was actively reaching out for help. I think the idea that people have in their minds of an abuse victim is someone who won’t reach out for help or they won’t take action.

Of course you get exhausted and run down and overwhelmed. Women that I talk to every day are amazing. Even though they feel that way, they keep putting one step in front of the other.

FEELING THE ANGER WHEN YOU REALIZE HE’S BLAME SHIFTING

Absolutely. I’ve spent two and a half decades with this person who I really tried to fix this with and really tried to make this work. We have a big family.

I was devastated. I was crushed, sometimes I didn’t believe it. I kept thinking, this isn’t my story. Like I would listen to stuff and I’d be like, no, no. I try to figure out ways to take me out of the similarities, try to convince myself like I was making the problems bigger than they were.

That’s something I would always be told too. The more I kept listening, this is it. This is what’s been going on. You can’t deny it anymore. I remember then I just got angry.

And I don’t even know if it was so much towards him, but really towards myself. Like, how could I have done this to myself? How would I allow another person do this to me for this long that I trusted, that I continued to have kids with, that I gave up my career for so he could advance his.

Where was I back then? Then I got motivated to really heal.

As I hear a lot of the women who share their stories, when we go in, we go all in. We’re gonna give it our best. That’s just how we are. We are dedicated, loyal, and when we wanna do something, we do it. And I think that was my problem with marriage.

I wanted it so bad, I wanted to fix it so bad, and okay, well that’s not gonna work. So let’s really work on getting myself healthy, getting myself where I need to be the best mom I can be for my kids now, and the best person I can be.

So that’s where I’m focusing my energy at this point. Getting to re-know myself to go back to who I really am. It changed me in so many ways.

Mm-hmm.

Yeah.

HEALING FROM THE INJURIES CAUSED BY BLAME SHIFTING

Anne: The, the whole idea of healing is interesting to me because we’ve been injured, so of course we need to heal. We’ve been hit by a metaphorical truck. But the idea that there’s something wrong with us is a different thing. So I always think of it like if you did get hit by a truck, no one would think it was weird if you sat in bed and watched TV. You can’t quite walk yet. You’re not fully functional because you’ve been injured.

You’re in pain and you’re having a hard time. So you need some help.

I like to think of it like that. Like we are having a hard time because we’re severely injured. But there’s nothing actually wrong with us.

I really wanna stress this. You’re not fixing something that’s wrong with you as you’re healing. You’re just literally healing from these injuries.

The mental injuries of having so many of his lies inside of our heads trying to purge them out. Our brain is healing, our body is healing from constantly being under stress. That really doesn’t a hundred percent heal until that stress is no longer happening anymore.

If you’re still going through that divorce, that stress is intense and it’s intense for a long time. There’s no way around it. You have to go through it and it’s awful. And I’m so sorry you’re going through that right now. It’s not fun.

LEARNING HOW TO SHOW UP FOR MYSELF AGAIN

Thank you Anne I really appreciate that. Everything that you said is completely true and I have experienced it up to this point. In some form it’s escalated and him getting the kids involved has been probably the hardest part. I keep learning more about that and how to approach that situation and keep showing up for my kids and just being there by action.

After I filed, it was just weird because I had always felt God was so distant from me through my marriage. The craziest thing, I feel like on this journey, God has been so close to me. Just little reminders of him and the things that he’ll do, or a feeling that I’ll get when I read something.

I’ll just share this because this was today. Through all of this, of course I had to get some employment. I’m working at the school where my kids are. My first grader I help in a different classroom. In the morning we were doing our announcements and prayers and I looked over at the window and she’s looking right at me, at her window in her classroom, I take that as a huge sign that I’m supposed to be where I’m at. I have to see God in this. I have to know at the end it’s gonna be okay. Because it has been so hard getting here and it’s so painful. The financial abuse, every part of it that I hear in all of these podcasts, I’m like, yep, yep.

Going through that. It doesn’t stop. It’s reminding myself that God is still here and he is actually in this and he’s helping me break free from all of the years of this.

My husband, that was also his biggest thing. He would tell the kids and himself is that God hates divorce. Your mother’s doing this. What does God feel about towards your mother then? That really takes a toll spiritually. The healing is shutting those negative voices out that my husband has implanted in my head for so many years.

And bringing in the truth, the good voices, and surrounding myself with the support of people that help me remember that every day. It is such a hard path to be on.

GOD LOVES TRUTH

Mm-hmm. God loves truth. God loves you. I think somebody said that to me once, they said God hates divorce. I turned to them and I said, “What are you talking about God loves divorce. Because he loves me.”

They looked at me like I was legit cray cray, but I, I was like, of course he loves me. Do you realize that this God hates divorce business, what it says to us is he hates us and that cannot be true in my mind. Everyone is welcome here. Whether you’re faith or agnostic or atheist or wherever you say you’re welcome here. Thank you for being here, as far as my beliefs, God loves me.

I am not a second class citizen. I’m important. Because he loves me, he loves my divorce. Maybe I won’t put it in general terms, but I am so proud to be divorced. People ask me and I’m like, I’m divorced because it is so hard to do. It’s one of the hardest things.

My feeling is not be ashamed, but it’s like. We’re getting a PhD in hard. And it’s worth being proud of. Your peace is worth being proud of.

Absolutely, that’s for me where I had to just reconcile that with myself and God, and know that those are more lies. And if God hates divorce, then that would mean that he loves abuse. No God is like that. That doesn’t even equate to a loving God that I know. No, I think it’s just fear tactics. It’s just ways to control and manipulate.

When people would say this to me, I hated it so bad. If they’d say, “There is a light at the end of the tunnel or you will make it through. I thought, “Maybe for you, but not for me.”

But it does, which is the good news. I would rather sit here because we need people to sit in the pain with while it’s happening, when it’s not better yet.

OVERCOMING THE ISOLATION OF BLAME SHIFTING

Yeah, I think that was a huge part. In our marriage he kept me so isolated, he ruined my friendships. So I never had support.

Because once I started having friends and felt supported. He lost it. I think for him that was when there was nothing he could do about it anymore.

I remember making friends with some ladies, I said, “Listen, just so you know, my husband’s gonna sabotage this, so we’re just gonna have it right out right now. This is what it’s gonna look like. This is what it always looks like. Just so you know.”

And sure enough, he tried, but they already knew because I had told them what could happen and he would start talking about me making up things. So I was able to cut all that off early. And keep them separate because I knew that’s how my life was going to go.

I was able to keep my support system. You can’t do this without support. You need to have your group, you need to have women like you 📍 📍 and the podcasts your community and support. There’s no way.

Yeah, and the good news is support is available. He will make it feel like it’s not, or that you don’t deserve it or that it’s gonna be dangerous or all of the things. The good news is all of the women who have been through this, we’ve been there. We know. Here at BTR I never tell women, “Just leave.”

Because it’s complicated and I don’t know what the answers are gonna be, but we support whatever she wants to do. Wherever she is, we’re here for that. That’s up to her to decide. I want all women to have peace and safety, but that is our only goal. Our goal isn’t divorce. Our goal isn’t to save the marriage.

It’s that she is peaceful and safe and that she’s not being harmed. However that’s gonna look for her it’s actually none of my business. We have strategies and support to give her along that path as she’s making those choices. That’s the other issue. Women have been so blamed and 📍 told you need to do this to save your marriage or you have to do this. So just saying these are the strategies to use to keep yourself safe, but you can make whatever choice you want is so empowering for women.

HOW TO HELP YOUR KIDS THROUGH THIS

Oh yeah. And I think for me too, I think us as moms, we are always thinking of our kids first. That was me. Like I stayed for the kids and I learned more through listening and my own healing and honestly, I’m leaving for the kids at this point. Now’s the time.

I want to live. I am in a spot where I feel like I can move out of that season into this season for myself. It’s all in timing. It’s all what you can deal with personally.

I think the thing that matters to me is just educating women so that they know. Because we don’t know what kind of choices I would’ve made or what kind of choices you would’ve made had we had the right information. So that’s the problem, and that’s not our fault, especially when we were trying to get help.

That has nothing to do with us. That’s where I see my role as, you can make whatever choice you wanna make. I would like to give you this correct information so that you know what you’re actually dealing with and you can deal with it strategically,

Even if I had learned it earlier, it doesn’t mean I would’ve left earlier. But having the knowledge and the information to at least know that you’re not crazy. So much of it is mental and emotional and psychological that I could have probably functioned better maybe in my situation. I could have known how to handle things a little bit differently instead of always wearing all of the guilt and all of the blame. That was constantly being fed to me.

Yeah, it’s a shift in perspective from thinking that there’s something that you can do to improve it, which is not true. To learning strategies and skills like tennis. You can learn how to serve better. You can learn how to backhand better.

The knowledge and skills of what’s happening and then how to protect yourself, which is a totally different thing. There’s no one that I ever went to and I don’t think you did either, from what you’ve talked about that was like. Let’s about how to protect yourself.

LEARNING HOW TO PROTECT YOURSELF

Oh no, no. And it’s funny ’cause as you said that it was something that reminded me that part of the therapy would always be like, there’s nothing wrong with bettering yourselves. So you’d always be wanting to better yourself. But then the whole thing, you’d be bettering yourself for trying to get healthier.

Meanwhile, you’re married to somebody who is not. And then half of me would be like, why am I doing this when I still have to live with this person?

Yeah, instead of saying, you’re great, you’re amazing. There’s nothing wrong with you. You’re fine. And you need to protect yourself from him ‘ because he is not healthy and he’s hurting you.

Well, it’s like comparing the little imperfections of normal relationship problems to huge problems. And somehow my husband always wanted the scale to be balanced. Like, ” You didn’t smile when I came home from work.” And I’m like, wait a minute. Maybe because you were just kissing somebody. How are those equal?

Right. It’s not only not equal, but it’s also, you didn’t actually do anything wrong. You don’t have to smile when he comes home from work. That’s not a thing.

Audrey, thank you so much for coming to share your story. I really appreciate it. If you’re interested in coming back on in a year and letting us know  📍 📍 how you’re doing , I would love to hear about that.

Oh, I would too. That would be great. Thank you so much, Anne.

What is Featurism

CONNECTING BLAME SHIFTING AND FEATURISM

Anne: We’re going to talk about that today with Dr. Jones. Featurism is basically the practice of valuing or prioritizing certain physical features over others.

Dr. Natalie Jones is here to talk about some of these issues. She received her Master’s in Clinical Counseling Psychology and her Doctorate in Clinical Psychology. Welcome, Dr. Jones.

Natalie: Thanks for having me on. My dissertation study was on African American women. Their parents psychologically abused them while growing up. And I identified certain elements of narcissistic abuse. Some examples would be colorism and featurism. Colorism, goes way back. It’s a comparison to whiteness and how closely a person of color or a black person relates to a person that’s white. That is then translated to be goodness or worthiness.

So for example, if I have more white presenting features, such as long straight hair, or I have light colored eyes or light colored skin. Certain people perceive me as a better version of a black person than someone who may be darker skinned or brown skin or doesn’t have those types of features.

People called it the paper bag test back in the day. That means Folks would compare their skin color to the paper bag. If you were darker than the paper bag, you were perceived not to be as beautiful or not as worthy. So that’s something specific to people of color.

BLAME SHIFTING AND COLORISM

Natalie: Where there’s this perception of lighter skin or what traditional white features is perceived as being better. I can’t make a broad general statement for every family, because colorism presents differently. In the traditional narcissistic family, you have the child, the golden child can do no wrong. And then you have the child, a scapegoat who Is blamed for everything and all of the family problems .

So when you have colorism at play, traditionally speaking, a lighter skinned child, more often than not, is the golden child. So they receive better treatment, more compliments, and people tell them they’re more beautiful. Whereas the scapegoat may be the darker or the brown skinned child. They may be perceived as not as beautiful, put down, degraded more, or comments made about their skin color. And receive just poor treatment.

Colorism is not just African American specific, it occurs in other families of color. And other races, ethnicities, and cultures of color. So I don’t want to put that out there that it’s not on a societal level. Colorism is something society grows to accept, and perpetuates. So what you actually see is an internalized racism that’s pushed within cultures.

Featurism Ways It Impacts Women

It would be comparison or breaking a person down. Degrading a person based on what their body features are. So, for example, if your nose is bigger, or you are bigger in size, or perhaps have a bigger butt. Those things sort of breaking a person down based on features and degrading them based on features.

Texturism was another one. So again, very similar to colorism. Texturism is specifically about the types of hair African American women have. So some hair is perceived to be, again, beautiful or better than other types of hair.

HOW FEATURISM AND SOCIETAL TRENDS ENCOURAGE ABUSE

Natalie: And so again, featurism is going back to qualities that are more white centered, being perceived as the standard of beauty. So if your hair is longer, if your hair is straighter, it’s automatically perceived to be much more beautiful. And the patterns of abuse attacking women and making them ashamed, and just breaking down their self esteem. And also making conditions of love, worthiness, or acceptance based on these types of features.

My research showed that typically speaking, you will have much more severe abuse with an intimate partner. Than you did in your family growing up. And this still remains the trend for many women of color today. It’s interesting, because I’m actually seeing it become a trend on TikTok. One of the things I noticed in the research I just talked about with my participants is that their partners did not like women of color.

This is Emotional Abuse!

So their partners actually preferred other types of women based on standards of beauty, which is what they’re told. But their partners, they did not like women of color, and I think they did not like women in general. Maybe think about someone who’s misogynistic. So a misogynist does not like women, right? So even though they may partner with someone, they tear everything down about that person. Or they tear everything down about that culture of that person.

So part of it is just breaking down that person’s being. They could say, oh, women, they’re too angry, too assertive, too headstrong, and can’t be controlled by their man. They need to be more submissive, thinner, have better hair or better presenting features to look like this.

RED FLAGS IN RELATIONSHIPS

Natalie: Even though they’re together and that person may have sex with you. They’re basically telling you daily that they hate everything about you, and they’re breaking that part of you down. It’s the same as a typical narcissist, right? But if you are ever dating someone, that is making statements about a race, that’s featurism. Especially their own race, and how they hate everything about it. For me, that is a huge red flag.

If a woman is dating a black man, and he says, I hate black women, or I don’t identify with those people. That is a red flag, because he has a mother. He may have an aunt, grandmother or sister.

Anne: Yeah, that’s problematic. So I’m white and I have a lot of white friends.

Natalie: Yeah.

Learn More about BTR Group Sessions

Anne: That same thing happens, but it’s generally not related to race, but it’s you’re not skinny enough, you’re too outspoken. This is why I created my betrayal meditations. Do you feel like that’s an extra burden for women of color to carry?

Natalie: Absolutely.

Anne: Because at least for all the white victims I’ve talked with, no one’s ever brought up race in relation to it. So, they’re adding an extra burden of race.

Natalie: Absolutely, most victims of abuse will spend a lot of time trying to change and mold themselves into someone worthy, because that’s what abuse does. And if you take a step back and look at it, not only from a micro level, meaning like just your family and people around you. It’s a bigger issue, because it’s also on a systemic and societal level. Traditionally speaking, there is a sense of oppression, and there is that sort of unspoken message that whiteness is better.

BLAME SHIFTING IN SYSTEMIC OPPRESSION & SOCIETAL MESSAGES

Natalie: Although, it becomes a sense of privilege when people can’t see that. Because that’s never been something they’ve ever had to worry about. Even just taking a look through your high end fashion magazines, what are you going to see? It’s on reality television. Those messages that you see. Absolutely. It’s something that women of color experience daily.

One of the things to remember is that society also backs that message up. Which also makes it much more difficult to overcome those types of oppression.

Anne: For all my wonderful black friends listening, let’s say like if you’ve listened to this podcast for a long time. You’ve heard women from all different races, religions, and areas of the planet. All of us are experiencing narcissistic abuse in ways that we’re not enough or too much. What is featurism? We’re all learning how to recognize victim blaming. One of those things, we’re, we’re never just right. And so knowing that you have an extra layer of burden. Also know that they’re not going to be happy with anything.

So even if he dated a woman, he deemed “perfect.” He said she had the perfect nose. And she had the type of skin color he said was attractive. He’d still be undermining her in so many ways, and he might be attacking the way she looks. He might be undermining her. There is no way to win. Because it’s not about anything else other than him maintaining power over and trying to put her down in any way he can.

At Betrayal Trauma Recovery, we do not diagnose anyone. I created BTR for women victims of emotional and psychological abuse and sexual coercion. Sexual coercion is usually in the form of someone using pornography and not informing their wife about it

FOCUS ON VICTIM SAFETY

Anne: And then she’s not able to give consent. As women victims come to us for help, we don’t diagnose their abusers. Because many victims come in and read something on the internet. And they’re like, oh, he’s a narcissist. And sure, he’s definitely acting like a narcissist. Or he’s got an addiction. And yes, he’s meeting the criteria for that. But instead of focusing on what’s causing these types of abusive behaviors, we focus on victim safety.

Are you emotionally, psychologically, and sexually safe?

Natalie: Yeah. I mean, what do you need a diagnosis for? Like figure it out for what? Like logically and rationally, what do I need that for? What is that going to get me? Usually when I encounter someone with that question, or that train of thought, that is still someone operating in survival mode. Every day that you’re being abused, or brutalized, or with someone taking advantage of you, you’re surviving. Although you may not feel like it, you still are surviving. That is that mentality.

Someone who’s oppressed has that mentality. It’s like, what can I do to fix this situation? Because someone who is abused is always told it’s their fault. And they need to fix something, right. That is the mindset when someone’s abused, that you need to fix someone else. Or if you have some answers, you can fix this person, or this person can get some help, or this and that and the other.

Having your own autonomy is you figuring out what’s going on with you and what you need in this moment. There’s nothing wrong with this man cognitively. So there’s no reason that cognitively they can’t get their own help.

EMPOWERMENT & REALIZATION

Natalie: If they want to, they will. So I would encourage you to think about what do you need? What is happening to me? Honestly, if you pay attention to yourselves. You can say, this person isn’t treating me well, this person is putting me down. And other people may help this person abuse me, put me down, or silence me. And that’s the information I need, that I don’t feel good about what’s happening here. They are hurting me, and I don’t like that.

And I think that is a much more empowering way to realize what’s going on and take care of yourselves. But when you ask questions like, is my partner a narcissist or is narcissism a mental illness, or what can I do to help them? You are typically looking at ways to help that person and not help yourself. That’s the whole premise of abuse being told you’re the problem. And so you need to fix it. An abusive person is constantly projecting the blame on you.

And telling you that you need to do X, Y, and Z to be good enough or worthy enough. Or for them to even consider loving you, right? And then they always change the goalposts. So again, that survivalistic thinking. That’s what you are conditioned to do. Because that’s all hammered into you. Whether it’s academics, like your grades need to be good enough, it’s you need to look pretty enough.

Or maybe you need to cook everything, clean everything, bend over backwards every day, and it’s still not good enough. And that’s why I always encourage people to look at the factual information and write it down on paper.

FOCUS ON THE FACTS IF HE’S BLAME SHIFTING

Natalie: Like what are the facts? Not what can I fix, what it should look like, or what do I want it to be like?

Anne: Or even what is he saying, because he’s gonna be saying stuff.

Natalie: Right.

Anne: Don’t even write that down. Don’t include his words as facts.

Natalie: Right, if he’s saying something but doing something totally different, that’s a fact. Like if he said, I’m going to be at your house Tuesday at nine o’clock, and he never showed up.He never showed up, that is a fact. But he lied and said he was going to do something else. That is a fact, right? And so just sort of writing down the facts, just what are the facts? Pay attention to how you feel.

Many times when people reach out to counseling, they’re focused on anxiety. And you know, my partner’s not communicating with me. So it’s important to pay attention to how you’re feeling. You need someone who is very objective, who is in the trenches with you, because there are some therapists that aren’t as good, aren’t as qualified to suss out abuse. Because we’re not thinking realistically about how dangerous a person is. We’re just thinking that we want to fix it.

Sometimes it could be a life or death situation that you don’t need to fix. You just need to get out, or otherwise the outcome isn’t going to be good for you. And that’s specifically why I say you need someone who’s realistic, objective, and can tell you. This person is significantly disturbed, and I need you to pay attention to what’s going on here. Because when you’re in it, you’re thinking in survival mode.

GET SUPPORT THAT KNOWS HOW TO TREAT BLAME SHIFTING

Natalie: If you think you are experiencing blame shifting related to featurism, You need someone who is objective, in reality. Focus on getting some support if you can, a lot of narcissistic abuse focuses on isolating you. If you can get your support online, this podcast has a handle on it, because not everyone understands.

Anne: Yeah, it’s hard to find the right support, which is exactly why I started podcasting. So yeah, you get it. Dr. Jones, thank you so much for spending time talking with me today.

Natalie: Absolutely, thanks I appreciate it talking to you.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published, and only the first initial of your name will be shown.

  • Overwhelmed by Self-Care After Betrayal? A Powerful Lifeline
  • How To Set Boundaries With My Husband – My Struggle
  • 5 Stages: How to Leave a Toxic Relationship When You Have Kids
  • “My Husband Hates Me” – The Devastating Truth I Didn’t Know
  • When Your Husband Apologizes – How to Know If It’s Genuine

    The most comprehensive podcast about betrayal trauma, Anne interviewed over 200 women (and counting) who bravely shared their stories. New episodes every Tuesday!

    Listen on any platform

    Top Betrayal Trauma Podcast